Microsoft Patent Claims Pose No Immediate Risk for Users

G00148911

Analyst(s): | |

  Free preview of Gartner research

Summary

Microsoft claims that a variety of open-source software projects violate its software patents. A general trend toward more aggressive patent licensing tactics is on the horizon.

News Analysis

Event

On 14 May 2007, Fortune magazine reported that Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith and Vice President of Intellectual Property and Licensing Horacio Gutierrez have claimed that free and open-source software (OSS) infringes on at least 235 Microsoft patents. Smith told Fortune that the Linux kernel violates 42 Microsoft patents, the Linux graphical user interfaces violate another 65 patents, and the Open Office suite of programs infringes on 45 more patents. E-mail programs allegedly infringe on 15, while other assorted open-source programs allegedly violate 68. Gutierrez refused to publicly identify specific patents or explain how they're being infringed.

Analysis

Gartner believes that Microsoft will not seek to litigate patent claims against users. Instead, we think the company will attempt to pressure technology providers to come to the table and negotiate an equitable licensing or royalty arrangement in instances where Microsoft can prove its claims of infringement.

IT providers have amassed software patent portfolios for many years. Patent agreements among vendors are commonplace among virtually all large technology vendors. The practice is well-established as the equivalent of a legal détente among vendors that rely on defensive patents to protect their own business strategies. Vendors can and often do use patents in an offensive strategy to create control points of technology and revenue opportunities as well.

Microsoft appears to be attempting to receive a return on its investments in R&D by creating revenue opportunities from, or cross-licensing deals with, OSS technology providers through its technology patent portfolio. It believes that companies receiving revenue from OSS that is, in part, based on Microsoft's innovations (in instances where this can be proven) should be subject to the same market dynamics that drive any other commercial technology strategies.

Microsoft thinks it can best deal with the issue of open-source patent infringement by creating partnerships (such as the agreement it entered into with Novell). However, the Free Software Foundation (FSF) has strenuously objected to these efforts and has attempted to foreclose on future agreements with its proposed addition to the GNU General Public License v.3.

We believe Microsoft's public announcement of these patent infringement allegations is an attempt to increase pressure on technology providers to accept patent agreements with Microsoft. The company has had some limited success in building such agreements with Novell and a number of other providers (most recently Samsung).

Gartner finds it interesting that Microsoft has chosen to make the patent information public. Vendors typically go out of their way to avoid public disclosure of patent agreements; moreover, companies typically attempt to avoid lawsuits insofar as they potentially threaten the patent portfolios they maintain. Proving patent viability in court is much more difficult and expensive than simply creating a royalty agreement. Such an effort would place further pressure on Microsoft to explicitly list the infringing patents, which it has declared to Gartner that it will do privately with the technology providers — not with individual developers or corporate users.

We believe Microsoft is strengthening its patent portfolio to rectify what it perceives to be exploitation of its intellectual property (IP) by technology providers that generate substantial revenue from OSS, including Linux. We do not believe Microsoft intends to pursue end-user IT organizations. Instead, we believe it will use the fear of legal compliance to pressure IT providers to enter into individual IP agreements. If suppliers balk or challenge Microsoft, this could escalate into a broader conflict as large-scale commercial open-source vendors (such as HP, IBM and Sun) are pulled into the conflict when their customers and partners turn to them for protection and support.

Recommendations

Organizations using OSS (such as Linux):

  • Don't panic or be concerned about paying Microsoft licensing fees. Despite Microsoft's allegations of IP infringements, it will have to fight for the validity of its patents in court. Even if Microsoft were proven correct, it would be highly unlikely to take an aggressive position with end users because most are also Microsoft customers.

  • Should Microsoft decide to go to court, the exact nature of its claimed patent infringements would then become apparent. Linux users would then need to consider the community's ability to address those issues.

IT providers:

  • Ascertain from Microsoft as specifically as possible where violations may occur. Prepare defensive measures (such as using your own IP for cross-licensing) or collaborative defensive strategies with close partnerships (such as IBM and others).

Recommended Reading

(You may need to sign in or be a Gartner client to access the documents referenced in this First Take.)

© 2007 Gartner, Inc. and/or its Affiliates. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction and distribution of this publication in any form without prior written permission is forbidden. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Gartner disclaims all warranties as to the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of such information. Although Gartners research may discuss legal issues related to the information technology business, Gartner does not provide legal advice or services and its research should not be construed or used as such. Gartner shall have no liability for errors, omissions or inadequacies in the information contained herein or for interpretations thereof. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.

Not a Gartner Client?

Want more research like this?
Learn the benefits of becoming a Gartner client.

Contact us online

  Research

More  

  Webinars

More  

Why Gartner

Gartner delivers the technology-related insight you need to make the right decisions, every day.

Find out more