Seventy-six percent of marketing leaders expect a decrease in marketing budgets due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a Gartner, Inc. survey of 360 marketers on 27 March 2020. An earlier poll in March of 176 marketers reported that budget cuts will hit advertising particularly hard with nearly half (45%) reporting a campaign launch had already been delayed, 34% had altered ad creative and 26% had already cancelled a media buy.
“Cuts to media spend are beginning to hit marketers hard – a reality that will likely worsen throughout 2Q20,” said Andrew Frank, distinguished vice president analyst in the Gartner Marketing practice. “Marketers need to take decisive action now to manage media budgets and ad strategies during, and well beyond, the COVID-19 public health crisis.”
The uniqueness of the COVID-19 pandemic has rendered predictive models based on historical data useless. The fluidity of conditions undermines test-and-learn approaches that require time and scale to produce reliable results. As a result, marketers must work together to develop strategies that can gain alignment and support with less data than they’re accustomed to and learn from their industry peers to develop a collective consensus on the path forward.
“While the effects of the coronavirus outbreak are felt globally, its business impact varies by industry sector,” said Eric Schmitt, senior director analyst in the Gartner Marketing practice. “Some sectors, such as travel and hospitality, have largely suspended all commercial operations. Others, like essential consumer goods, are experiencing spikes in demand due to hoarding. For many others, the effects are less clear.”
Gartner has broken up these sectors into three categories: dark sectors, shaded sectors and spotlit sectors:
Dark Sectors: Conserve and Centralize
Dark sectors are those where shelter-in place policies have caused many to suspend commercial operations completely – such as nonessential brick-and-mortar retail, sports and live entertainment, and travel and hospitality. Marketers in these dark sector businesses need to conserve media budgets while pandemic conditions persist and focus on providing useful updates directly to loyal customers.
“Centralize control of media spend to avoid regional noncompliance with communication policies and take advantage of programmatic channels that can be rapidly ramped up or down depending on changing local conditions,” said Mr. Schmitt. “Marketers should beware of returning to promotional tactics that may have worked well previously, even in the recent past, as consumers are likely to reject a rapid return-to-business-as-usual approach.”
Shaded Sectors: Monitor and Remain Agile
Shaded sectors are those that remain operational but have been impacted by plummeting demand or supply chain restrictions. This includes automotive, B2B products and services, energy and utilities, high-tech and telecom, and luxury, among others. These sectors must continue to monitor media and creative strategies, and avoid being absent from markets where competitors are running media campaigns.
“Marketers in these sectors should seek value propositions and narratives that explicitly acknowledge the pervasive condition of social distancing and limited mobility,” added Mr. Frank. “Work closely with agencies and other advisors to vet strategies and make real-time adjustments to campaigns as conditions change and consumers respond more directly on social media.”
Spotlit Sectors: Focus on Safety and Combat Misinformation
Spotlit sectors are those on the front line of the COVID-19 pandemic such as news media, essential consumer goods, over-the-counter pharmaceuticals, healthcare, insurance, grocers, restaurant chains and delivery services. These businesses are repurposing advertising channels to convey vital information to customers who are directly impacted by the health crisis.
“Marketers in these sectors should use local media buys to promote safe, contactless home delivery and service options where available, and help combat misinformation,” Mr. Frank said. “Those businesses with vital messages should prioritize reputable media sources, such as national news media, and use extreme care with social media to avoid proximity to misinformation.”
Additional information on what marketing leaders should be doing amid COVID-19 is available to Gartner for Marketers clients in the report “How to Advertise in Uncertain Times: Lessons from COVID-19.”
Learn more about how to lead organizations through the disruption of coronavirus in the Gartner coronavirus resource center, a collection of complimentary Gartner research and webinars to help organizations respond, manage and prepare for the rapid spread and global impact of COVID-19.
About Gartner for Marketers
Gartner for Marketers provides the objective, expert advice and proven tools that CMOs and other marketing leaders need to seize the right opportunities with clarity and confidence, and to stay ahead of the trends that matter. With in-depth research and analysis, Gartner for Marketers helps you focus on the opportunities with the greatest potential to deliver results. More information on Gartner for Marketers is available online at www.gartner.com/marketing.